Skip to content

Reflections on the Final Report on the Participation of Women in the Life and Leadership of the Church

by Clevie Youngblood, RSHMCategory: Updates

At the June 13 Area Day celebration of the Feast of the Sacred Heart of Mary, Sisters Catherine Vincie and Luisa Almendra presented their reflections on the Synod’s Final Report of Study Group 5: The Participation of Women in the Life and Leadership of the Church. Sister Catherine noted the report’s significance as an ecclesial document that “put in writing” key issues regarding women’s leadership of the Church. It is a step forward, but very cautious about actions that could be taken. She highlighted some “gems” in the document which emphasize women as vital members of the Church. Recognizing the signs of the times that indicate the alienation of women from the Church, the document says the Church must address this problem. “There is a risk that failure to listen and address the present discomfort of many women could compromise the Church’s fidelity to mission.” (6)

The document notes the Spirit-inspired and “essential contribution of women to the evangelizing mission of the Christian community.” (8) It states that Church history attests to the abilities and charisms of women as witnesses of faith, leaders of institutions and in parishes, theologians, and promoters of human dignity and social justice. It recognizes that in our own time women have been called and inspired by the Spirit to preserve and hand on the faith as community leaders in places with few or no priests, and their presence in the roles of authority has not posed a problem. (30) Because they are bearers of charisms and baptized members, women possess the right to fuller participation in the life and governance of the Church.

two women sitting at table with blue/green african cloth covering it. One woman with short grayish hari an glasses and other owman with black pageboy and glasses with laptops open in front of them
L to R: Sister Catherine Vincie and Sister Luisa Almendra

Sister Luisa described the document’s structure and addressed the important issue of women’s voices and models in ecclesial documents and the scriptures. She noted that specific descriptions about women in the life and leadership of the Christian community were found only in the Appendix. The document itself quotes from the final document of the Synod on Synodality, which “specifically recommended paying greater attention ‘to the language and images used in preaching, teaching, catechesis, and the drafting of official Church documents, giving more space to the contributions of female saints, theologians, and mystics.’” (FD par. 60)(4) The Lectionary is another example of where women’s stories are neither included nor their importance emphasized. As a biblical scholar, she suggested that any study of the lectionary readings should not only acknowledge women’s stories but also include an understanding of how biblical authors from different periods show and hide women in the stories.

Sister Catherine explained the concept of power and authority as presented in the document, specifically the source of power and women’s ability to exercise it. While noting that women and men are together “partakers of the same mission within an ecclesial context of communion” (21), the document distinguishes two powers:

  • a. the power derived from administration of the Eucharist, reserved to the ordained
  • b. the power delegated by the Roman Pontiff.

It is through this delegation of power that Pope Francis and Pope Leo have appointed women to head curial offices and dicasteries. Such appointments would not extend to positions requiring Holy Orders. Sister Louisa commented that the Vatican is moving forward on the issue of women’s leadership, if cautiously, and is setting an example. Hopefully, dioceses and parishes will follow this example.

The need for discernment and openness to Spirit-led activity is evident in the document. “Wherever there is a need for evangelization, the Spirit has already bestowed a charism upon someone” (33), including women because the Spirit acts as it will. (34) The document is a step forward, putting in writing basic tenets for reflection and action on the issue of women’s roles that cannot now be ignored.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *